How to Handle an Underperforming Sales Rep (Without Firing Them)

Address Underperformance Before It Becomes a Bigger Problem

Performance issues can occur in any sales force. Sometimes, a sales rep who was previously delivering excellent results may find it hard to achieve the expected results by missing targets, generating pipeline, or converting leads. However, the poor performance has to be handled; otherwise, an immediate reaction to fire the employee might ignore the root cause.

Instead of making assumptions and firing the person for no reason, it is necessary to figure out what causes the drop in performance and decide whether something can be done about it. The sales rep might experience a lack of skills, low pipeline volume, unclear expectations, inappropriate sales techniques, lack of assistance, or any difficulties related to the sales process. Understanding the root cause will help in dealing with it more effectively.

Successful sales management includes both accountability and assistance. Managers have to define the performance expectations, discuss the problems openly, coach the employees appropriately, and monitor their performance.

Identify What is Causing the Underperformance

Managers will not be able to rectify the underperformance until they know exactly what is going on. It is not enough to look at the failure to hit the sales quota.

First of all, you have to see whether the sales representative's current performance differs from their targets and past performance. You can look at such key performance indicators as revenue, quota achievement, pipeline building, conversion rate, win rate, average deal size, and sales cycle time. They can show you what is wrong.

For instance, a sales rep may demonstrate very good activity numbers but a low conversion rate. This may show that the person has issues with qualification, discovery, value proposition, or closing. Another sales rep can show a decent conversion but have a low pipeline, which means that there is something wrong with prospecting or lead generation.

Moreover, there are other things that can influence a salesperson's results, and managers need to take them into account too.

The goal here is to figure out the reason behind poor performance first of all.

Have a Direct Performance Conversation

After pinpointing the issue, it needs to be discussed directly. This way, bad performance will not be tolerated further and will provide the rep with clarity on the matter.

A performance discussion should be based on facts. The person discussing the matter needs to point out the expected level of performance, actual performance results, and the gap between them. Data-based conversations are always more objective and provide salespersons with something they can work with.

At the same time, the discussion needs to give sales reps the opportunity to state what is going on. Maybe the rep is already aware of the issue and holds some facts that cannot be seen from the numbers. For example, maybe the representative finds it hard to deal with certain customers, is facing problems because of the ineffective sales process, or does not feel confident about certain stages of the sales cycle.

Discussing is not about lowering the standards. This stage is needed in order to collect enough information about the situation and understand what kind of action needs to be taken.

Find the Specific Skills or Behaviors That Need Improvement

A failing sales rep does not have to improve all aspects of their performance at once. The managers need to pinpoint what exact skills, behaviors, or steps of the sales process cause most of the performance issues.

One salesperson may have the prospecting phase as the major weakness, while another may find many prospects but be unable to qualify them well. One rep may demonstrate good performance throughout the sales process except for the negotiation and closing phases.

Reviewing the performance on actual sales calls can help to identify what the problem is. Managers can look into the outcomes of the calls, the progress of opportunities, the ratio of proposals and closes, etc.

Another thing is to differentiate the skill issue from the process issue. Sometimes, the salespeople are aware of the way to perform a certain task, but do not have a system to implement it properly. Then, an improved process might work better than additional training.

Selecting a few areas that can significantly impact performance makes the whole improvement process more feasible.

Create a Practical Performance Improvement Plan

Once you identify the problem, develop an actionable performance improvement plan. It should aim to transform your broad expectations, for example, "improve performance," into something more concrete and measurable.

First, identify what needs to improve. The objective should be clearly linked to the gaps in performance that have already been identified. For instance, you can choose to increase qualified pipeline, enhance conversion rates, reduce response times, or increase quota attainment within a certain period of time.

You should not set a single target but consider setting some checkpoints along the way. Milestones help you understand whether improvement has taken place and the strategy being followed is working.

Another element that should be included in a performance improvement plan is how the process will be evaluated. You need to make sure the sales rep knows what metrics to pay attention to, how often results will be evaluated, and what a successful improvement looks like.

A useful improvement plan helps you establish accountability but also gives you a clear vision of what is expected. The sales rep is not left to guess anymore, and you have a tool for evaluation.

Provide Targeted Coaching and Support

Performance plans become much more useful when there is proper support behind them. Simply telling the sales representative what the problems are and not offering any solutions will most likely not solve the problem.

The coaching must correspond to the specific weakness. For example, if the problem is prospecting, then the manager can coach on prospecting techniques, messaging, qualifying, and follow-up. If the weakness is closing, then the manager can concentrate on dealing with objections, buying signals, and closing techniques.

Role-playing is effective when communication skills are concerned. Analyzing past transactions is useful as well; sales representatives can learn from mistakes and see what they can do differently.

Proper support can also include better tools, processes, training, and internal resources. The manager needs to make sure that the sales representative has all they need to reach the goals.

Good coaching is concrete, practical, and ongoing. Instead of telling the sales representative about the consequences of bad performance, the coaching should give them something to work on.

Track Improvement With Clear Performance Metrics

When you start using your selected intervention, the next step would be to monitor how the salesperson is performing. Here, performance measurement will be crucial.

Select some number of relevant performance metrics that could be used to evaluate whether the improvement plan is effective. For example, if your focus is on generating the pipeline, then pipeline value and quality may be more important metrics compared to some other metrics that have nothing to do with your plan.

Pay attention to trends, not just one-time results. Sales performance may be unstable, which means that you shouldn't get disappointed when the salesperson performs poorly just once. However, sustained improvement in a particular direction will give you a much clearer picture.

Moreover, make sure to have frequent talks with the salesperson in order to find out how the process is going and what should be changed in your plan.

In general, measuring the performance here will help you to determine whether the intervention is working.

Know When Further Action Is Necessary

There are instances where even the underperforming sales representatives will not react to coaching or additional support. It is therefore necessary for managers to come up with what will happen if the underperformance persists despite attempts to correct the situation.

The first thing that needs to be determined is whether the sales representative has had an opportunity to make improvements. Has there been communication of performance expectations? Have all the problems been identified? Have there been any attempts at providing coaching or support? Have measurable objectives and reviews been made?

Where there are improvements, the emphasis can be on development. Improvements do not happen instantly, and there are some performance issues that require time to fix.

However, in cases where the underperformance persists despite the above measures being put in place, more management action may be required. Any decisions pertaining to employment must follow the existing organization's policies and employment requirements.

The key thing here is consistency. Decisions pertaining to performance must be based on documented performance and expectations and not frustrations.

Conclusion: Convert Poor Performance into a Course Correction

The management of poor sales performance should not be only about making a decision on whether to retain or terminate the employment of the individual involved. First, one needs to diagnose what is going wrong and whether there is a way to address that issue.

One should start with facts by comparing reality with expectations and finding out the exact element that is responsible for the performance problem. Then, one should engage in an open dialogue, set goals for improvement, conduct coaching, and track the results using relevant sales performance metrics.

In this way, the person gets an honest chance to correct their course, while the standards of the sales department remain intact. What is more, the process allows managers to make decisions based on facts rather than assumptions.

Poor-performing sales reps should be made accountable; however, such accountability would work only if expectations are clearly communicated and support provided.

Call-to-Action

For anyone that wants any further guidance, ClickAcademy Asia is exactly what you need. Join our class in Singapore and enjoy up to 70% government funding. Our courses are also Skills Future Credit Claimable and UTAP, PSEA and SFEC approved. Find out more information and sign up here. (https://www.clickacademyasia.com/course/sales-performance-management).